科学网—swu1963的留言板

IP: 192.168.0.* [8]董文鸳 2013-12-19 10:12

尊敬的用户：
您好！若您有使用Google Scholar的经历，我们诚恳地邀请您参与“科研人员使用Google Scholar的影响因素”的问卷调查。网址是：http://www.sojump.com/jq/2979618.aspx。非常感谢您的配合！

IP: 122.225.72.* [7]袁顺波 2013-4-1 13:21

尊敬的科学网博客用户：
您好，诚恳地邀请您参与“科学网博客用户持续使用的影响因素”问卷调查，网址是：
http://www.sojump.com/jq/2250398.aspx，本次调查需要3-5分钟的时间，非常感谢！

IP: 58.166.69.* [6]吴树彪 2012-10-11 17:15

I agree what Prof Zare's view about H-Index if all other ways of assessment can be comparable. I never think any of the assessments such as H-Index, citations or IP can be subjective enough to reflect the academic levels of everybody. However, when you need a method, probably you have to choose a more subjective one. That's the point really. For those extremes, I never believe any of the assessments even peer review can be fair at least at some stages. For example, in Steven Weinberg's case, nobody or no system would identify him or recognize his work during years 1967, 1968 or even a bit later. So, what I mean is whatever system is just relatively better.

IP: 115.58.179.* [5]lk0703 2012-9-11 22:51

It is about H-(index .http://bbs.sciencenet.cn/home.php?mod=space&uid=99360&do=blog&id=611350)

IP: 115.55.65.* [4]lk0703 2012-8-28 15:11

Thanks for your reply .Wish you have a nice day

我的回复(2012-8-29 19:10)：Not a problem. You too!

IP: 115.58.180.* [3]lk0703 2012-8-25 22:14

Dear Professor Wu/Dear Mr Wu:
I am very happy to meet you on this forum.if h-index is a very popular index of evaluating a scholar's level, but Baidu shows it can not be used in the Interdisciplinary study . so Iam confused .Could you please explain it ? Thank you very much
.

我的回复(2012-8-27 19:53)：I am not quite clear what exactly you are referring as I haven't came across with Baidu's statement. I think H-index is a good reference to see how well the researchers are, but any such index or the way of assessment will inevitably have bias in one way or another. I too believe it's not useful to compare two scientists in quite distant areas using any indexes including H-index. Hope this answered your question.

IP: 115.58.180.* [2]lk0703 2012-8-25 22:13

Dear Professor Wu/Dear Mr Wu:
if h-index is a very popular index of evaluating a scholar's level, but Baidu shows it can not be used in the Interdisciplinary study . so Iam confused .Could you please explain it ? Thank you very much

IP: 60.223.239.* [1]罗广营 2012-1-9 19:50

Dear Dr Shubiao Wu,
Glad to see you! I'm Guangying Luo, a candidate Ph.D. in SXAU. Thank you for your last revising for my paper.
Best wishes!
yours
Guangying Luo

swu1963的个人博客分享 http://blog.sciencenet.cn/u/swu1963

留言板

吴树彪