武夷山分享 http://blog.sciencenet.cn/u/Wuyishan 中国科学技术发展战略研究院研究员;南京大学信息管理系博导

博文

美国科学开放性的一个小例子 精选

已有 9887 次阅读 2010-4-3 07:06 |个人分类:他山之石|系统分类:海外观察

武夷山

 

口服避孕药之父、科学文学的身体力行者Carl Djerassi教授在200473日出版的Science杂志发表短文Asian Brains: U. S. v. Europe(利用亚洲的头脑:美国与欧洲的对比),文章说:

Science杂志2000324日(287卷总5461期)发表了一篇研究果蝇(Drosophila)基因组的论文,它是34家实验室的186位科研人员共同完成的,186位作者中,有51位从姓名写法可判断出是亚洲国家的人,其中多数是中国人。同一期杂志上还发表了另一篇研究Drosophila基因组的论文,该文共有47位作者,从姓名看,清一色是欧洲人。

 

博主:前面提到的第一篇文章作者如下,第一作者是美国科学家:

Mark D. Adams, 1* Susan E. Celniker, 2 Robert A. Holt, 1 Cheryl A. Evans, 1 Jeannine D. Gocayne, 1 Peter G. Amanatides, 1 Steven E. Scherer, 3 Peter W. Li, 1 Roger A. Hoskins, 2 Richard F. Galle, 2 Reed A. George, 2 Suzanna E. Lewis, 4 Stephen Richards, 2 Michael Ashburner, 5 Scott N. Henderson, 1 Granger G. Sutton, 1 Jennifer R. Wortman, 1 Mark D. Yandell, 1 Qing Zhang, 1 Lin X. Chen, 1 Rhonda C. Brandon, 1 Yu-Hui C. Rogers, 1 Robert G. Blazej, 2 Mark Champe, 2 Barret D. Pfeiffer, 2 Kenneth H. Wan, 2 Clare Doyle, 2 Evan G. Baxter, 2 Gregg Helt, 6 Catherine R. Nelson, 4 George L. Gabor Miklos,7 Josep F. Abril, 8 Anna Agbayani, 2 Hui-Jin An, 1 Cynthia Andrews-Pfannkoch, 1 Danita Baldwin, 1 Richard M. Ballew, 1 Anand Basu, 1 James Baxendale, 1 Leyla Bayraktaroglu, 9 Ellen M. Beasley, 1 Karen Y. Beeson, 1 P. V. Benos, 10 Benjamin P. Berman, 2 Deepali Bhandari, 1 Slava Bolshakov, 11 Dana Borkova, 12 Michael R. Botchan, 13 John Bouck, 3 Peter Brokstein, 4 Phillipe Brottier, 14 Kenneth C. Burtis, 15 Dana A. Busam, 1 Heather Butler, 16 Edouard Cadieu, 17 Angela Center, 1 Ishwar Chandra, 1 J. Michael Cherry, 18 Simon Cawley, 19 Carl Dahlke, 1 Lionel B. Davenport, 1 Peter Davies, 1 Beatriz de Pablos, 20 Arthur Delcher, 1 Zuoming Deng, 1 Anne Deslattes Mays, 1 Ian Dew, 1 Suzanne M. Dietz, 1 Kristina Dodson, 1 Lisa E. Doup, 1 Michael Downes, 21 Shannon Dugan-Rocha, 3 Boris C. Dunkov, 22 Patrick Dunn, 1 Kenneth J. Durbin, 3 Carlos C. Evangelista, 1 Concepcion Ferraz, 23 Steven Ferriera, 1 Wolfgang Fleischmann, 5 Carl Fosler, 1 Andrei E. Gabrielian, 1 Neha S. Garg, 1 William M. Gelbart, 9 Ken Glasser, 1 Anna Glodek, 1 Fangcheng Gong, 1 J. Harley Gorrell, 3 Zhiping Gu, 1 Ping Guan, 1 Michael Harris, 1 Nomi L. Harris, 2 Damon Harvey, 4 Thomas J. Heiman, 1 Judith R. Hernandez, 3 Jarrett Houck, 1 Damon Hostin, 1 Kathryn A. Houston, 2 Timothy J. Howland, 1 Ming-Hui Wei, 1 Chinyere Ibegwam, 1 Mena Jalali, 1 Francis Kalush, 1 Gary H. Karpen, 21 Zhaoxi Ke, 1 James A. Kennison, 24 Karen A. Ketchum, 1 Bruce E. Kimmel, 2 Chinnappa D. Kodira, 1 Cheryl Kraft, 1 Saul Kravitz, 1 David Kulp, 6 Zhongwu Lai, 1 Paul Lasko, 25 Yiding Lei, 1 Alexander A. Levitsky, 1 Jiayin Li, 1 Zhenya Li, 1 Yong Liang, 1 Xiaoying Lin, 26 Xiangjun Liu, 1 Bettina Mattei, 1 Tina C. McIntosh, 1 Michael P. McLeod, 3 Duncan McPherson, 1 Gennady Merkulov, 1 Natalia V. Milshina, 1 Clark Mobarry, 1 Joe Morris, 6 Ali Moshrefi, 2 Stephen M. Mount, 27 Mee Moy, 1 Brian Murphy, 1 Lee Murphy, 28 Donna M. Muzny, 3 David L. Nelson, 3 David R. Nelson, 29 Keith A. Nelson, 1 Katherine Nixon, 2 Deborah R. Nusskern, 1 Joanne M. Pacleb, 2 Michael Palazzolo, 2 Gjange S. Pittman, 1 Sue Pan, 1 John Pollard, 1 Vinita Puri, 1 Martin G. Reese, 4 Knut Reinert, 1 Karin Remington, 1 Robert D. C. Saunders, 30 Frederick Scheeler, 1 Hua Shen, 3 Bixiang Christopher Shue, 1 Inga Sidén-Kiamos, 11 Michael Simpson, 1 Marian P. Skupski, 1 Tom Smith, 1 Eugene Spier, 1 Allan C. Spradling, 31 Mark Stapleton, 2 Renee Strong, 1 Eric Sun, 1 Robert Svirskas, 32 Cyndee Tector, 1 Russell Turner, 1 Eli Venter, 1 Aihui H. Wang, 1 Xin Wang, 1 Zhen-Yuan Wang, 1 David A. Wassarman, 33 George M. Weinstock, 3 Jean Weissenbach, 14 Sherita M. Williams, 1 Trevor Woodage, 1 Kim C. Worley, 3 David Wu, 1 Song Yang, 2 Q. Alison Yao, 1 Jane Ye, 1 Ru-Fang Yeh, 19 Jayshree S. Zaveri, 1 Ming Zhan, 1 Guangren Zhang, 1 Qi Zhao, 1 Liansheng Zheng, 1 Xiangqun H. Zheng, 1 Fei N. Zhong, 1 Wenyan Zhong, 1 Xiaojun Zhou, 3 Shiaoping Zhu, 1 Xiaohong Zhu, 1 Hamilton O. Smith, 1 Richard A. Gibbs, 3 Eugene W. Myers, 1 Gerald M. Rubin, 34 J. Craig Venter 1

第二篇文章作者如下,第一作者是英国科学家:

Panayiotis V. Benos, 1 Melanie K. Gatt, 211 Michael Ashburner, 12 Lee Murphy, 3 David Harris, 3 Bart Barrell, 3 Concepcion Ferraz, 4 Sophie Vidal, 4 Christine Brun, 4 Jacques Demailles, 4 Edouard Cadieu, 5 Stephane Dreano, 5 Stéphanie Gloux, 5 Valerie Lelaure, 5 Stephanie Mottier, 5 Francis Galibert, 5 Dana Borkova, 6 Belen Minana, 6 Fotis C. Kafatos, 6 Christos Louis, 78 Inga Sidén-Kiamos, 7 Slava Bolshakov, 67 George Papagiannakis, 7 Lefteris Spanos, 7 Sarah Cox, 7 Encarnación Madueño, 9 Beatriz de Pablos, 9 Juan Modolell, 9 Annette Peter, 10 Petra Schöttler, 10 Meike Werner, 10 Foteini Mourkioti, 10 Nicole Beinert, 10 Gordon Dowe, 10 Ulrich Schäfer, 10 Herbert Jäckle, 10 Alain Bucheton, 4 Deborah M. Callister, 11 Lorna A. Campbell, 11 Areti Darlamitsou, 11 Nadine S. Henderson, 11 Paul J. McMillan, 11 Cathy Salles, 11 Evelyn A. Tait, 11 Phillipe Valenti, 11 Robert D. C. Saunders, 1112 David M. Glover 211

 

2010331日搜索Google Scholar,第一篇文章已经被引用3333次,而第二篇文章被引次数只有23次。当然,第一篇属于综述评论文章,这类文章往往被引次数较高。但是,两篇文章被引次数相差如此之大,恐怕与文章作者队伍的开放性还是有关系的。

 

 



https://wap.sciencenet.cn/blog-1557-308505.html

上一篇:词语之妙(之二)
下一篇:您佩服哪一类人?(外二则)
收藏 IP: .*| 热度|

24 王铮 杨学祥 王桂颖 段明 郑融 陈儒军 张檀琴 俞立平 王号 钟炳 王修慧 吉宗祥 盖鑫磊 魏瑞斌 吕乃基 柳东阳 李学宽 张旭 李泳 许培扬 唐常杰 李毅伟 丛远新 侯振宇

发表评论 评论 (9 个评论)

数据加载中...
扫一扫,分享此博文

Archiver|手机版|科学网 ( 京ICP备07017567号-12 )

GMT+8, 2024-4-30 05:09

Powered by ScienceNet.cn

Copyright © 2007- 中国科学报社

返回顶部