刘跃
推翻现行微波吸收理论框架的一篇综述
2024-5-30 20:57
阅读:699

1 推翻现行微波吸收理论框架的论文(综述 )

Wave mechanics of microwave absorption in films: A short review

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.optlastec.2024.111211

image.png

Wave mechanics of microwave absorption in films: a short reviewOptics and Laser Technology2024178,  111211 

在微波吸收领域,有大量综述文章发表(该文本身就引用了很多综述文章),但是这一篇综述与众不同。

这一篇综述大胆地指出现行理论的问题。

--------------------------

当你做为普通人时,你应该谦虚、应该委婉;

别人做错了也不能直接指出来让人家下不来台。

但是当你做为科学家时,你必须旗帜鲜明,必须敢于与人家不同、敢于坚持真理。

科学就是质疑;你好,我好,大家都好就不会有科学 

Vazire, S., 2020. A toast to the error detectors. Nature. 577, 9.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-019-03909-2

http://finance.sina.com.cn/hy/20131119/105717365753.shtml

http://finance.sina.com.cn/hy/20131119/105717365756.shtml

张维迎:创新就是大部分人都不认同的想法

https://www.wenmi.com/article/puj98i03nn9k.html

多数人认同的不叫创新

https://www.yicai.com/news/5345088.html

许小年:创新没有风口,凡是追逐风口的行为都不是创新https://www.sass.org.cn/_s3/_t31/2008/1229/c1201a26145/page.psp

但“创新”意味着与众不同,公认的东西往往是常识

====================

有人说科学家也是人,因此科学家也会像普通人那样做不道德的事。

但是在科学问题上, 科学家是不准许在学术上做不道德的事。

----

当你做为普通人时,你可以说谎;你说谎只是你自己的问题。

但是当你做为科学家时,你错了,你就必须承认错误。因为你要对其它科学家负责人、要对普通大众负责人。

你要坚持真理,你就不能圆滑,你就拿不到项目经费。

建议原创者打疫苗:One Way Ticket, 1979, Eruption 

“you should not fool the layman when you're talking as a scientist. 

I am not trying to tell you what to do about cheating on your wife, or fooling your girlfriend, or something like that, when you're not trying to be a scientist, but just trying to be an ordinary human being. We'll leave those problems up to you and your rabbi. 

I'm talking about a specific, extra type of integrity that is not lying, but bending over backwards to show how you're maybe wrong, that you ought to have when acting as a scientist. 

And this is our responsibility as scientists, certainly to other scientists, and I think to laymen.”

2 推翻现行微波吸收理论框架的论文(2024年)

  1.  Yue Liu,Ying Liu,Michael G. B Drew. ReviewWave mechanics of microwave absorption in films: a short reviewOptics and Laser Technology2024178,  111211 (The wave mechanics for microwave absorption film-Part 1: A short review, Preprint, Research Square, 15 Aug, 2023, scite)

  2. Yue Liu,Ying Liu,Michael G. B Drew,Wave Mechanics of Microwave Absorption in Films - Distinguishing Film from MaterialJournal of Magnetism and Magnetic Materials2024, 593, 171850 ;     ( The wave mechanics for microwave absorption film – Part 2: The difference between film and material,Preprint, Research Square, 15 Aug, 2023, Supplementarial file)

  3. Yue Liu, Michael G. B Drew,Ying Liu, A Theoretical Exploration of Impedance Matching Coefficients for Interfaces and FilmsApplied Physics A2024, 130, 212

  4. Ying Liu, Michael. G.B. Drew, Yue LiuChapter 4: Fundamental Theory of Microwave Absorption for Films of Porous Nanocomposites: Role of Interfaces in Composite-Fillers, in Porous Nanocomposites for Electromagnetic Interference Shielding, Edited by: Sabu Thomas, Claudio Paoloni, Avinash R. Pai2024Elsevier, [978-0-323-90035-5_B978-0-323-90035-5.00013-1], pp. 59 - 90, https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-323-90035-5.00013-1

  5. Yue Liu, Ying Liu, Drew MGB,  [Commentary] Comments on: “A perspective on impedance matching and resonance absorption mechanism for electromagnetic wave absorbing” by Hou et al. [Carbon 222 (2024) 118935]Qeios2024Supplementary 

  6.  Yue Liu, Ying Liu, Drew MGB, Corrections of common errors in current theories of microwave absorption caused by confusing film and materialQeios2024/02/10, preprint, https://doi.org/10.32388/QQ1MFF;  Corrections of Common Errors Associated with the Confusion between Film and Material in Current Theories of Microwave Absorption. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4797207 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4797207

3 推翻现行微波吸收理论框架的论文(2017 年 -- 2024 年)

推翻现行理论的文章很难发表,这些文章的发表都是在不可能发出来的情况下侥幸发表出来的。

普朗克科学定理:

“A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it” M. Planck, Scientific Autobiography and Other Paper, William & Norgate, London, 1950, pp. 33 -34.

The Quarter-Wavelength Theory of Microwave Absorption Has Been Debunked II (growkudos.com)

但是回头看看,无论多么困难,成系列的文章还是发表出来了。

颠覆性创新是极少数人做出来的,颠覆性成果的发表也是极少数的编辑和审稿人放行的结果。

科学正是这些极少数人顶着巨大的压力推进的。

科学的进步绝不是投票投出来的。

当全社会都否定你时,不见得是你错了;

当所有期刊都拒你的稿子时,你很被动,但是不见得是你的稿子不行。

有意思的是:

颠覆性创新经常以没有创新、不重要的名义被拒稿(一般指不出稿件论证的问题),

垃圾文章则是以有重大创新、重大意义的名义发表。

然而,

正确的东西,只要发表出来就赢了,即使整个世界都不承认。

“Beyond these considerations, the importance of many of the more recent developments 

cannot be evaluated objectively at this time. The history of mathematics teaches us 

that many subjects which aroused tremendous enthusiasm and engaged the attention 

of the best mathematicians ultimately faded into oblivion ... Indeed one of the interesting 

questions that the history answers is what survives in mathematics. History makes its own 

and sounder evaluations.” 

--Morris Kline, Mathematical Thought from Ancient to Modern Times, 

Oxford University Press, 1972, ISBN 0-19-506136-5 

引申:

历史是最公正的。历史反复证明,那些在当世喧嚣尘上的东西往往是主流学者刻意炒作的糟粕,

而那些被当世打压的经常是真金白银。 

Expansion: History serves as the ultimate arbiter. It consistently reveals that what is often overemphasized by the prominent 

scholars of an era is often merely the intentional promotion of mediocrity, 

while that which is suppressed by the prevailing contemporary scholars often reveals 

itself to be authentic and of true value.

  1.  Yue Liu,Ying Liu,Michael G. B Drew. ReviewWave mechanics of microwave absorption in films: a short reviewOptics and Laser Technology2024(The wave mechanics for microwave absorption film-Part 1: A short review, Preprint, Research Square, 15 Aug, 2023, scite)

  2. Yue Liu,Ying Liu,Michael G. B Drew,Wave Mechanics of Microwave Absorption in Films - Distinguishing Film from MaterialJournal of Magnetism and Magnetic Materials2024, 593, 171850 ;     ( The wave mechanics for microwave absorption film – Part 2: The difference between film and material,Preprint, Research Square, 15 Aug, 2023, Supplementarial file)

  3. Yue Liu,Ying Liu,Michael G. B Drew, The wave mechanics for microwave absorption film-Part 3: Film with multilayers, Preprint, Research Square, 13 Aug, 2023,Supplementarial filescite_

  4.   Yue Liu, Michael G. B Drew,Ying Liu, A Theoretical Exploration of Impedance Matching Coefficients for Interfaces and FilmsApplied Physics A2024, 130, 212

  5. Ying Liu, Michael. G.B. Drew, Yue LiuChapter 4: Fundamental Theory of Microwave Absorption for Films of Porous Nanocomposites: Role of Interfaces in Composite-Fillers, in Porous Nanocomposites for Electromagnetic Interference Shielding, Edited by: Sabu Thomas, Claudio Paoloni, Avinash R. Pai2024Elsevier, [978-0-323-90035-5_B978-0-323-90035-5.00013-1], pp. 59 - 90, https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-323-90035-5.00013-1

  6. Yue Liu, Ying Liu, Drew MGB,  [Commentary] Comments on: “A perspective on impedance matching and resonance absorption mechanism for electromagnetic wave absorbing” by Hou et al. [Carbon 222 (2024) 118935]Qeios2024Supplementary 

  7.  Yue Liu, Ying Liu, Drew MGB, Corrections of common errors in current theories of microwave absorption caused by confusing film and materialQeios2024/02/10, preprint, https://doi.org/10.32388/QQ1MFF;  Corrections of Common Errors Associated with the Confusion between Film and Material in Current Theories of Microwave Absorption. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4797207 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4797207

  8. 刘颖, 刘跃膜的微波吸收机理, 分子科学学报, 2023,v.39; No.194(06) 521-527

  9. Ying Liu, Kaiqi Yang, Yue Liu, Michael G. B Drew, The Shackles of Peer Review: Unveiling the Flaws in the Ivory TowerarXiv, https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2310.05966

  10. Ying Liu, Michael G. B. Drew, Yue Liu, A physics investigation on impedance matching theory in microwave absorption film—Part 1: Theory, Journal of Applied Physics2023, 134(4), 045303, DOI: 10.1063/5.0153608

  11. Ying Liu, Michael G. B. Drew, Yue Liu, A physics investigation on impedance matching theory in microwave absorption film—Part 2: Problem AnalysesJournal of Applied Physics2023, 134(4), 045304, DOI: 10.1063/5.0153612

  12. Ying Liu; Xiangbin Yin; M. G. B. Drew; Yue Liu, Microwave absorption of film explained accurately by wave cancellation theoryPhysica B: Condensed Matter2023, 666, 415108. (Microwave absorption of film explained accurately by wave cancellation theory2023-02-23 | Preprint, Research Square, DOI: 10.21203/rs.3.rs-2616469/v2Supplementary information: Available comments and our responses.)

  13. Ying Liu, Yi Ding, Yue Liu, Michael G. B. Drew. Unexpected Results in Microwave Absorption – Part 1: Different absorption mechanisms for metal-backed film and for materialSurfaces and Interfaces2023, 40, 103022

  14. Ying Liu, Yi Ding, Yue Liu, Michael G. B. Drew. Unexpected Results in Microwave Absorption – Part 2:. Angular effects and the wave cancellation theorySurfaces and Interfaces, 2023, 40, 103024

  15. Ying Liu, Xiangbin Yin, Michael G. B. Drew, Yue Liu, Reflection Loss is a Parameter for Film, not MaterialNon-Metallic Material Science2023, 5(1): 38-48.

  16. 刘颖,丁一,陈庆阳,刘跃,NiFe2-xMxO4 (M: Ce/Sm/Gd)的制备及其膜的微波吸收性能沈阳师范大学学报 ( 自然科学版 )2023, 41(2),98 - 103

  17. Ying Liu, Yue Liu, Drew M.G.B, A re-evaluation of the mechanism of microwave absorption in film – Part 1: Energy conservationMater. Chem. Phys2022, 290,126576.

  18. Ying Liu, Yue Liu, Drew M.G.B, A re-evaluation of the mechanism of microwave absorption in film – Part 2: The Real mechanismMater. Chem. Phys,. 2022, 291, 126601.

  19. Ying Liu, Yue Liu, Drew M.G.B, A re-evaluation of the mechanism of microwave absorption in film  Part 3: Inverse relationshipMater. Chem. Phys2022, 290, 126521.

  20. Liu YLiu Y, Drew MGB. A theoretical investigation of the quarter-wavelength model  part 2: verification and extensionPhysica Scripta 2022 , 97(1) 015806.

  21. Liu Y, Liu Y, Drew MGB. A theoretical investigation on the quarter-wavelength model — part 1: analysisPhysica Scripta 2021 , 96(12) 125003. ( The problems in the quarter-wavelength model and impedance matching theory in analysising microwave absorption material, 2021-08-30 | Preprint, Research Square, DOI: 10.21203/rs.3.rs-206241/v1)

  22. Liu Y, Drew MGB, Li H, Liu Y. A theoretical analysis of the relationships shown from the general experimental results of scattering parameters s11 and s21 – exemplified by the film of BaFe12-iCeiO19/polypyrene with i = 0.2, 0.4, 0.6Journal of Microwave Power and Electromagnetic Energy 2021 , 55(3) 197-218.

  23. Liu Y, Drew MGB, Li H, Liu YAn experimental and theoretical investigation into methods concerned with “reflection loss” for microwave absorbing materialsMaterials Chemistry and Physics 2020 , 243 122624.

  24. Liu Y, Lin Y, Zhao K, Drew MGB, Liu YMicrowave absorption properties of Ag/NiFe2-xCexO4 characterized by an alternative procedure rather than the main stream method using “reflection loss”Materials Chemistry and Physics 2020 , 243 122615

  25. 赵坤 , 林雨冉 , 刘颖 . 微波吸收复合材料 Ag/NiFe2-xCexO4 的制备与表征功能材料 2020 , 51(03) 03171 - 03175.

  26. Liu Y, Drew MGB, Liu Y. Characterization microwave absorption from active carbon/BaSmxFe12−xO19/polypyrrole composites analyzed with a more rigorous method. Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Electronics 2019, 30(2) 1936-1956.

  27. Yang K, Liu Y, Drew MGB, Liu Y. Preparation and characterization of BaSmxFe12 − xO19/polypyrrole composites. Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Electronics 2018 , 29(15) 13148-13160Electronic supplementary material.

  28. Liu Y, Zhao K, Drew MGB, Liu Y. A theoretical and practical clarification on the calculation of reflection loss for microwave absorbing materialsAIP Advances 2018 , 8(1) 015223.

  29. Liu Y, Yu H, Drew MGB, Liu Y. A systemized parameter set applicable to microwave absorption for ferrite based materialsJournal of Materials Science: Materials in Electronics 2018, 29(2) 1562-1575,Supplementary material.

  30. Liu Y, Tai R, Drew MGB, Liu Y. Several Theoretical Perspectives of Ferrite-Based Materials—Part 1: Transmission Line Theory and Microwave AbsorptionJournal of Superconductivity and Novel Magnetism 2017 , 30(9) 2489-2504.

  31. Liu Y, Jin J, B. Drew MG, Liu Y. Several Theoretical Perspectives of Ferrite-Based Materials—Part 2: Close Packing Model for Crystal StructureJournal of Superconductivity and Novel Magnetism 2017 , 30(10) 2777-2789.

4 科学进步是任何人阻挡不了的历史进程

Weixin Image_20240530054355.jpg

Weixin Image_20240530054608.jpg

Weixin Image_20240530054826.jpg

Weixin Image_20240530054921.jpg

Weixin Image_20240530055104.jpg

Weixin Image_20240530055224.jpg

Weixin Image_20240530055333.jpg

Weixin Image_20240530055412.jpg

Weixin Image_20240530055553.jpg

转载本文请联系原作者获取授权,同时请注明本文来自刘跃科学网博客。

链接地址:https://wap.sciencenet.cn/blog-3589443-1436266.html?mobile=1

收藏

分享到:

当前推荐数:5
推荐到博客首页
网友评论4 条评论
确定删除指定的回复吗?
确定删除本博文吗?