曾庆平
男人肥胖预示“女性化”? 精选
2014-6-17 07:11
阅读:9793
标签:男人, 女性化, 雌激素, 豆制品

把肥胖解释为单纯由能量摄入失衡引起不足以说明人们对饮食及生活方式的不同响应范围,而生理学及解剖学变异可能与肥胖现象有关。

澳大利亚阿德莱德大学的研究人员近日在PLoS One发表文章,破天荒地提出了一个男人肥胖预示“女性化”的假说,即男人肥胖现象是因为体内雌激素过多而引起的。

作者提到,来自贫困家庭的女孩比她兄弟都要胖,而富裕家庭却不出现这种情况,这说明雌激素对脂肪积累有很大影响,不管其经济条件有多差。

在西方发达国家,男女肥胖率大致相当,而贫困国家的肥胖则是女多于男。作者发现,女性对男性的肥胖比例与日常用品总数成反比,由此得出结论:发达国家男女肥胖人数相等甚至胖男多于胖女是因为男性接触环境中雌激素类物质的结果。

这种环境中的雌激素类物质即“外源雌激素”(xenoestrogen)主要来自豆制品(异黄酮)及聚氯乙烯塑料,而西方国家尤其是美国的豆制品消耗量极大。作者指出,激素之所以能增加体重,是因为它们能抑制甲状腺的功能,同时还能控制下丘脑的运作。

这个假说的主体针对的是西方男人,但东方男人的情况应与此类似。理由是:西方男人的“女性化”已使精子数量大幅度降低,而东方男人精子锐减的现象不是也很常见吗?

我认为,这项研究结论虽然被“谦虚”地冠以假说,但还是由相当丰富和完整的数据得的,只是尚未通过实验加以证实。不过,下面的研究结果似乎支持本文的结论,只是对雌激素来源的解释不同。

篇报道(Obesity may influence heart function through sex hormones)这么说:睾酮(一种雄激素)可以通过芳香酶转变成雌二醇(一种雌激素),其活性在肥胖者中增强,使得雌二醇升高,而睾酮降低

你认为这个研究结论靠谱吗?如果回答是肯定的,男人就少吃豆腐、少喝豆浆吧!如果你觉得是无稽之谈,那就照吃不误!

我不妨照此发挥一下:小伙子想变胖,多吃豆腐;个性暴躁的“胡须男”要让性格变得柔和一点,多吃豆腐!再进一步推论,大姑娘太瘦,怎么吃也不胖,那是雌激素分泌不够,也要多吃豆腐!哈哈,信不信由你!

以下是原文的题目和摘要:


The Estrogen Hypothesis of Obesity


The explanation of obesity as a simple result of positive energy balance fails to account for the scope of variable responses to diets and lifestyles. It is postulated that individual physiological and anatomical variation may be responsible for developing obesity. Girls in poor families develop greater adiposity than their male siblings, a trend not present in richer environments. This indicates strong influence of estrogen on fat accumulation irrespective of poor socioeconomic conditions. Obesity rates in males and females of developed nations are similar, while in poorer nations obesity is much more prevalent in females. Female to male ratio of obesity correlates inversely with gross domestic product. Therefore, the parity of male and female obesity in developed countries may result from male exposure to environmental estrogen-like substances associated with affluence. These hormonally driven mechanisms may be equally active within both sexes in more developed areas, thereby increasing overall obesity.


以下是Science Daily的相关报道:


Are female hormones playing a key role in obesity epidemic?

Date:
June 13, 2014
Source:
University of Adelaide
Summary:
An imbalance of female sex hormones among men in Western nations may be contributing to high levels of male obesity, according to new research. Scientists suggest that obesity among Western men could be linked with exposure to substances containing the female sex hormone estrogen -- substances that are more often found in affluent societies, such as soy products and plastics.


"In some Western nations, male obesity is greater than female obesity. While poor diet is no doubt to blame, we believe there is more to it than simply a high caloric intake," Mr Grantham says.
Credit: © bahrialtay / Fotolia

An imbalance of female sex hormones among men in Western nations may be contributing to high levels of male obesity, according to new research from the University of Adelaide.

In a paper published in the online journal PLOS ONE, researchers from the University's School of Medical Sciences suggest that obesity among Western men could be linked with exposure to substances containing the female sex hormone estrogen -- substances that are more often found in affluent societies, such as soy products and plastics.

The research was conducted by University of Adelaide medical student James Grantham and co-authored by Professor Maciej Henneberg, Wood Jones Professor of Anthropological and Comparative Anatomy.

Mr Grantham compared obesity rates among men and women from around the world with measures such as Gross Domestic Product to determine the impact of affluence on obesity. He found that while it was normal for women in the developing world to have significantly greater levels of obesity than men, the developed world offers quite a different picture.

"Hormonally driven weight gain occurs more significantly in females than in males, and this is very clear when we look at the rates of obesity in the developing world," Mr Grantham says.

"However, in the Western world, such as in the United States, Europe and Australia, the rates of obesity between men and women are much closer. In some Western nations, male obesity is greater than female obesity.

"While poor diet is no doubt to blame, we believe there is more to it than simply a high caloric intake," Mr Grantham says.

Professor Henneberg says: "Exposure to estrogen is known to cause weight gain, primarily through thyroid inhibition and modulation of the hypothalamus. Soy products contain xenoestrogens, and we are concerned that in societies with a high dietary saturation of soy, such as the United States, this could be working to 'feminize' the males. This would allow men in those communities to artificially imitate the female pattern of weight gain.

"Another well-established source of xenoestrogen is polyvinyl chloride, known as PVC. This product is in prominent use in most wealthy countries, from plastic medical devices to piping for our water supplies."

Professor Henneberg says micro-evolutionary changes may be occurring within Western societies that could also be leading to changes in testosterone and estrogen in men. "This would certainly explain the various concerns about sperm count reductions among men in developed nations," he says.

Professor Henneberg and Mr Grantham say further research is needed to better understand whether or not environmental factors are leading to a "feminization" of men in the Western world.

Story Source:

The above story is based on materials provided by University of Adelaide. Note: Materials may be edited for content and length.

Journal Reference:

James P. Grantham, Maciej Henneberg. The Estrogen Hypothesis of Obesity.PLoS ONE, 2014; 9 (6): e99776 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0099776


转载本文请联系原作者获取授权,同时请注明本文来自曾庆平科学网博客。

链接地址:https://wap.sciencenet.cn/blog-281238-803975.html?mobile=1

收藏

分享到:

当前推荐数:22
推荐到博客首页
网友评论24 条评论
确定删除指定的回复吗?
确定删除本博文吗?