杨小军分享 http://blog.sciencenet.cn/u/xiaojunyang Email: yangxiaojun2007@gmail.com

博文

information sciences 终于录用了

已有 25672 次阅读 2012-8-21 19:32 |个人分类:心得体会|系统分类:科研笔记| Information, SCIENCES, 层次分析法, CDHA

2011年1月11日投稿
6个月的时候催了一次
2012年1月11日一周年催了一次
2012年1月18日一审意见
Although the reviewers recommend "Minor Revision", their suggestions are sufficiently strict and correspond more to "Revise Major".
主审稿人说:I generally evaluate it as above the average I tend to see on the majority of related texts who pass the peer-review process everywhere - so I strongly recommend it for publication. 其他审稿人都给的肯定意见,小修,没提大问题。不过,主编还是给了大修。
2012年2月28日返回修改稿R1
2012年4月3日二审意见
Accepted with minor revison.
The paper is near to be accepted. Please, improve the language quality.
The linguistic quality needs improvement. It is essential to make sure that  the manuscript reads smoothly- this definitely helps the reader fully appreciate your research findings. Consult a professional. Show all changes made to the revised manuscript.
2012年4月7日返回修改稿R2
2012年4月16日三审意见
Accepted with minor revison.
The linguistic quality needs improvement. It is essential to make sure that  the manuscript reads smoothly- this definitely helps the reader fully appreciate your research findings. Consult a professional. Show all changes made to the revised manuscript.
It is important that  your study carefully refers to the most recent and highly relevant research results reported in the literature. Consider expanding  the list of references by adding more recent journal papers (published after 2010) including those published in INFORMATION SCIENCES.
2012年4月19日返回修改稿R3
2012年7月31日四审意见
Accepted with minor revison.
Editor in Chief
The linguistic quality needs improvement. It is essential to make sure that the manuscript reads smoothly- this definitely helps the reader fully appreciate your research findings. Consult a professional. Show all changes made to the revised manuscript. 
还是改语言,竟然审了3个多月!最后只是要求改语言。
实在没办法,改了3次语言主编还不满意。
到网上看了网友对这个期刊的评价:
waitingYHVH@小木虫:今天收到信,最后一个reviwer终于搞定了,只是恶心的编辑还要我们改英文。这样的要求,我只能理解为让我们去孝敬elsevier的英文修改服务。也委实让我们组里面帮忙改文章的美国labmate相当无语。
zhongnanliuhui@小木虫:对英语要求真高,外导改了好几次 现在还是提出语言问题。

xuqy1981@小木虫:最近被录用一篇文章,对英语的要求非常严格,不错的杂志。

看到这些,就知道这个期刊对英语的要求有多么变态了。最后没办法,找了个润色公司帮忙修改了一下语法,其实也没什么大的实质的改动,我的论文很长,50页,将近12000单词,句型修改的只有5、6处,替换了5、6个单词,有2、3处改了下时态,2、3处加了连词,4、5处加了冠词。其实,发现改后和之前并没有很大的提高,改之前论文就已经非常清楚了。只能理解这个期刊对语言太精益求精了。

今天2012年8月21日终于收到录用通知了,崩溃!

We are pleased to inform you that your article has now been accepted for publication in Information Sciences.

论文题目是:How to handle uncertainties in AHP: the Cloud Delphi Hierarchical Analysis

关于层次分析法AHP。

 


https://wap.sciencenet.cn/blog-431053-604499.html

上一篇:1个月内收到2次 IEEE Transactions on Fuzzy Systems 的审稿邀请
下一篇:information sciences 论文已上网
收藏 IP: 117.136.36.*| 热度|

1 许培扬

该博文允许注册用户评论 请点击登录 评论 (0 个评论)

数据加载中...

Archiver|手机版|科学网 ( 京ICP备07017567号-12 )

GMT+8, 2024-4-19 06:20

Powered by ScienceNet.cn

Copyright © 2007- 中国科学报社

返回顶部